Expertise

Expectation vs. reality: The critical role of consistency in retail experiences

Strategies to bridge the omnichannel retail experience

Consumer habits have fully reverted to the “old normal” and shoppers have returned to brick-and-mortar stores in droves—once again shopping on weekends, after work and at moments in-between. The stakes are now raised for retailers who poured resources into perfecting their e-commerce platforms during the pandemic: customers now demand that the in-person shopping experience aligns with their digital expectations.

And while consumers do conduct the majority of shopping research online, according to Forrester Research, they are just as likely to purchase products from a retailer in their physical store as they are on their website (see below).

This reality poses a pivotal question for retailers: What strategies will ensure their relevance in this dynamic landscape?

Forrester Research Survey on consumer shopping activity

Incongruous experiences: A cautionary tale

The line between digital and in-store shopping has disappeared completely. Consumers no longer view these channels as distinct entities but rather as one interconnected shopping journey. Consistency across the omnichannel experience is paramount for brands to remain competitive.

Consider this scenario: A customer discovers a product online via a retailer’s website and it checks all the boxes—it’s exactly what they need. Ready to make that purchase, they visit the store only to find that the inventory was incorrect or that the in-store experience fails to meet their expectations. The customer leaves disappointed and empty-handed, likely turning to a competitor. This lack of consistency becomes a loss in revenue.

Marketers used to hold true to the belief that brand loyalty was built over time—through a series of positive experiences. But in today’s era of e-commerce immediacy, brand loyalty is established both instantly and incrementally—and all it takes is one bad experience to put that loyalty in jeopardy.

As brands navigate the complexities of delivering a consistent omnichannel experience, there are three strategies to bridge the digital-to-physical gap

Invest in the physical store

Years removed from the pandemic, retail is on the rebound. We’ve seen the resurgence of traditional retail players—with the likes of JC Penny, IKEA and even Netflix breaking ground on new stores. These businesses are not alone—one recent survey indicates that retailers are expecting more of a return to pre-pandemic normalcy this year, as more than 30% of retail survey respondents anticipated opening additional locations in 2024.

With shoppers indicating a preference to shop in-store, the time is right for retail investment. Despite the proliferation of expedited and same-day delivery services, consumers still crave the immediacy and tactile experience that only brick-and-mortar stores can provide. If online is about convenience, then in-store is about experience.

It’s imperative for brands to seize this moment by creating dynamic in-store experiences that cater to the customer’s needs and streamline the shopping journey. Implementing retail decor packages that value the customer’s time—helping them to find the right product and shop the best deals—are small wins that offer big payoffs. And the rise of retail media networks grants brands more access to consumers, in-store as well as online, capturing an audience that is already predisposed and primed to purchase.

Brands that invest in their physical footprint today will benefit as consumers continue to seek a balance of in-store and online retail experiences.

Sync loyalty and personalization efforts, online and in-store

Customer satisfaction and loyalty requires interchangeable online and in-store experiences, but the data captured from these two experiences is often kept separate. Connecting physical and digital data effectively allows brands to create unique experiences that customers want to receive, driving engagement, loyalty and repeat purchase.

Machine learning and predictive AI technologies are also streamlining the shopping journey, helping customers get to the products they need, faster.

Consider the weekly grocery shop. The vast majority of shoppers still conduct their weekly shop in person. And while their list might change from one trip to the next, many of the items purchased—the household staples—remain the same. When an ecommerce shopper logs into their grocery account, they are prompted: “Fill your cart with your last order?” This simple algorithm provides incredible convenience to the shopper—streamlining this weekly task, and granting more time back to the customer to potentially increase their cart size further.

And for brands that capture rich first-party customer data, loyalty and personalization becomes much more dynamic. Shoppers receive offers that are created just for them, rather than a broad user demographic. These strategies give customers compelling reasons to visit the store.

The best loyalty and personalization programs consider a customer’s experience with their brand holistically, at all touchpoints, and use that information to continually optimize their omnichannel strategy.

A consumer browsing a retail website

Differentiate fulfillment with branded experiences

Among the number of retail trends catalyzed by the pandemic, one standout phenomenon is here to stay: convenience-driven fulfillment. Buy online, pick up in-store (BOPIS) and other delivery services are now permanent fixtures in the omnichannel experience.

While sufficient data, technology and labor investments are key inputs to a successful fulfillment operation, exciting opportunities exist for retailers to bring their brand to life across this channel.

Delivery trucks, for instance, operate as moving billboards, advertising omnichannel convenience. These vehicles afford retailers the opportunity to go big with a brand impression and offer a playful wink or nod of personality.

Omnichannel fulfillment can also deliver unexpected moments of surprise and delight. For example, Target, whose BOPIS system is lauded as one of the best in the industry, recently launched “Drive Up With Starbucks” at more than 1,700 retail stores.

This savvy move by the retailer allows Target customers to pair a Starbucks purchase with their drive-up order. Target advertised the offering as “yet another way we are energizing—and easing—the shopping experience.” The service delivers an upscale experience that competitors like Walmart and Amazon can’t match, further differentiating their pickup option.

The opportunity? While omnichannel fulfillment is, at its core, an operational business function, the retailers doing it best realize how to put their brand identity front and center—creating authentic experiences that recognize and respond to the needs of their customers.

Building a consistent omnichannel retail strategy

It’s never been more difficult for retailers to manage their omnichannel priorities. Consumer expectations are high, and economic and market pressures are constant. As shoppers increasingly engage in both online and in-store experiences, retailers are forced to make tough decisions when implementing their omnichannel strategy.

The solution to this challenge, while not simple, is clear: be customer-obsessed. A customer-first organizational mindset ensures that all operational decisions—from retail investment and e-commerce to loyalty programs and fulfillment—are executed with the brand’s most important stakeholder in mind: the consumer.

PREV STORY
This is some text inside of a div block.
BACK TO ALL
This is some text inside of a div block.
NEXT STORY
This is some text inside of a div block.
next
Lights, camera, results: See our demo reel
nextElderly woman kisses a smiling younger woman wearing a face mask, capturing a tender moment of love and connection.
Spreading the (add)love
nextGiant chocolate chip cookies spill from a laptop screen as miniature people observe and interact, symbolizing internet cookies and data tracking.
Cookie deprecation, could it be a boon?
nextIllustrated woman blows colorful icons—hearts, globes, and chat bubbles—symbolizing communication, connection, and digital expression.
Breathing personality into your B2B communication: 3 ways to connect with customers
nextbehind the scenes photo of brand slam podcast
Brand Slam: The winning brands podcast
nextWoman sits at a cluttered desk facing a large monitor, surrounded by books, maps, and a bulletin board filled with notes and photos.
From mind to market: The art and science of storytelling
nextHand sketching storyboard frames with pencil, illustrating animated characters and scene planning on paper.
What is an animatic?
next(add)venturists and their moms
Inspired by moms
nextBright yellow daffodils bloom in front of a modern gray building with “(ad)” lettering under a clear blue sky.
Leadership promotions at (add)ventures
nextDiverse group of people holding rainbow Pride flags, smiling and celebrating together outdoors under a clear sky.
Celebrating Pride Month with (add)love
next
Father’s Day reflections
nextColorful tulips bloom in front of a white industrial building labeled “20 RISHO” on a sunny spring day.
Meet our (add)prentice summer 2024 interns
next
Stop solving the wrong problem: CMOs hidden advantage
next
The future of sports marketing
next
Enjoy the dig
next
Expectation vs. reality: The critical role of consistency in retail experiences
next
Where creative people can thrive
next
Bringing retail spaces to life with experiential design
nextTwo teenage girls smiling and looking at a phone together, sitting in front of a colorful bookshelf.
How brands can interact with “gen angzt”
nextTraining room styled as a CVS store with tables, chairs, and clipboards, surrounded by realistic pharmacy and clinic wall graphics.
Inspiring the leaders of tomorrow through hands-on learning
nextSmiling volunteers hold fresh corn in front of a Hope’s Harvest RI truck, wearing (add)love shirts and sunglasses.
Gleaning for good
nextPride flags line the walkway outside (add)ventures’ headquarters, celebrating LGBTQ+ inclusion with vibrant colors against a black-and-yellow building.
Pride, powered by (add)love
nextHand holding a smartphone displaying a video of a woman drinking coffee, with Spanglish text beside it reading: “¿Listo para el weekend? Grab your cafecito y ponte las pilas que vamos shopping.”
Se habla Spanglish: Why bilingual ads win in today’s market
nextSilhouetted people walking near stadium and city buildings, overlaid with colorful location pins and abstract geometric shapes on a textured background.
The power of place
nextWoman holding megaphone labeled “Brand champion” surrounded by colorful speech bubbles and abstract shapes on green background.
The B2B maze, where complexity meets opportunity
nextThree women sitting at a table with laptops, smiling and chatting during a meeting in a bright office setting.
Welcoming our 2025 (add)prentices
next
Smarter marketing in leaner times: How CMOs can do more with less
nextClose-up of honeybees clustering on a wooden hive frame filled with capped and uncapped honeycomb cells.
Bee NICE: Our brand is buzzing
nextColorful bus stop ad displays the question ‘What defines your brand?’ next to a bench where two people sit, facing away.
Controlling the controllables: The importance of a “singular” brand
nextTwo women lead a workshop discussion with a large Post-it easel listing strategic points on care, geography, and multi-prong solutions.
From siloed to synced: Ways to unite sales and marketing
nextTwo mirrored maze diagrams with a bold orange arrow cutting through the center, symbolizing clarity and direction.
Simplifying the complexity of large projects
nextPedro Pascal and Bad Bunny stand smiling on the Saturday Night Live stage, lit by spotlights with a live band behind them.
[SPEAKING NON-ENGLISH]
nextYellow circular badge with red text ‘#Stop Latino Coating’ and black text ‘Join the New Minority Majority’ and ‘stoplatinocoating.com’ on a black background.
#StopLatinoCoating
next
Virtual production: Unlocking infinite creative possibilities
nextVibrant tree sprouts from an open book, symbolizing knowledge and growth.
The importance of sustainability and purpose-driven storytelling
nextCollage of fries with ketchup, Heinz packet, girl in snow, LEGO bricks, and Yoda minifigure.
Truths be told
nextHands hold a tablet showing a girl and guinea pig touching noses, CSR report cover.
Paws for impact: Putting pets and purpose first
nextWoman in dark blazer smiling in front of colorful framed artwork on a gray wall.
Mary Sadlier promoted to president of (add)ventures
nextYellow flowers in focus with wind turbines blurred in the background at sunset.
Three trends shaping sustainability communications
nextIllustrated group of professionals collaborating at computers, surrounded by AI and tech icons on a yellow circuit-themed background.
Five tips for collaborating with AI: Preparing for 2025
nextSmiling man in front of oversized quotation marks and a microphone, suggesting a podcast or interview setting.
Forecasting the future: CEO Steve Rosa on 2025’s game-changing predictions
nextLarge group of smiling coworkers posing indoors, many holding cards, in front of a small decorated holiday tree.
(add)love impact in 2024
nextProfessionals engaged in a meeting around a conference table, with laptops, drinks, and one participant pointing while speaking.
Creating the best client experience
nextIsometric diagram showing patient care settings—Emergency, Med-Surg, Critical, Surgical, and At-Home—connected within a digital healthcare ecosystem.
Decoding health marketing: Strategies that thrive and missteps to avoid
next
Meet an integral player in brands’ media mix: Retail media networks
nextIndoor climbing wall centerpiece in a two-level Sporting store surrounded by athletic apparel and gear.
Turning retail stores into brand experiences
nextProfessional production studio featuring a high-resolution curved LED wall displaying a serene lake and mountain scene, with a camera positioned on a raised platform.
Virtual production expands—and levels up
nextModern gray-and-yellow building with large (add)ventures logo on the side, set against a bright blue sky and landscaped with spring tulips.
(add)ventures elevates three to vice president
nextTwo volunteers from (add)ventures distribute Valentine’s treats and chat warmly with two elderly women in a sunlit room decorated with red hearts.
Spreading love, one valentine at a time
nextLarge colorful banner at HIMSS25 shows diverse healthcare professionals with the slogan “Creating Tomorrow’s Health” above a bustling convention floor.
HIMSS 2025: Context is king
nextMultiple smartphones display influencer food Reels on Instagram, featuring smiling creators, colorful dishes, and giveaway content on a blue background.
Influencers gonna influence
nextIan Brownhill smiling beside bold text “Beyond Likes & Follows,” promoting his podcast on authentic digital engagement.
Building better influencer partnerships
nextPhoto of Gen Z individuals engaging with phones, framed inside a browser window graphic overlaid with repeated text: “GEN Z BRAND LOYALTY.”
Gen Z’s trust test: Can your brand pass?

stay inspired, stay informed

Multidisciplinary, multicultural, multigenerational and multiversed insights—curated by (add)ventures for leaders ready to drive exponential growth. Our Multiplicity newsletter delivers global ideas designed to help you think bigger and stay ahead.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.